The Inferential Typology of Language: Insights from Sign Language (ASL)
Philippe Schlenker, Jason Lamberton, Jonathan Lamberton
February 2025 

Contemporary formal pragmatics has uncovered a rich inferential typology in spoken languages, one that includes at-issue contents, presuppositions, implicatures, homogeneity inferences, supplements and expressives. The division of informational contents among this typology is sometimes taken to be specified in the lexicon, but gestural research has argued against this view: with one possible exception (expressives), participants productively divide the content of iconic representations among the slots of the inferential typology, and this can be shown with pro-speech (= word-replacing) gestures as well as with novel visual animations. Despite important recent developments, sign language semantics has not systematically investigated this inferential typology. Based on published and new data from ASL, we do so from a dual perspective: we exhibit the characteristic behavior of different inferential types in lexical signs, but also (when applicable) in iconically modulated constructions, notably classifier predicates. These have a lexically specified form but an entirely free position and movement in signing space, which are interpreted iconically and give rise to truth conditions that couldn't be stored lexically. Classifier predicates thus make it possible to replicate the productivity argument from pro-speech gestures and visual animations, but with greater ease and precision because, unlike pro-speech elements, they are a common and fully integrated part of sign language. They also address an objection to findings coming from pro-speech gestures and visual animations, namely that these are in essence codes for normal expressions of spoken language (words); this objection has no plausibility for ASL iconic constructions, as these are normal expressions of sign language. Besides highlighting the importance of sign language for formal pragmatics, our study makes a broader point: any analysis of sign language must provide an explicit treatment of its iconic component and of its interaction with the inferential typology. [The published version is available at: https://rdcu.be/efgth]

Format:	[ pdf ]
Reference:	lingbuzz/007646 (please use that when you cite this article)
Published in:	To appear in Natural Language & Linguistic Theory
keywords:	semantics, pragmatics, sign language, asl, scalar implicatures, presuppositions, supplements, cosuppositions, expressives, homogeneity, semantics
previous versions:	v5 [February 2025] v4 [July 2024] v3 [November 2023] v2 [October 2023] v1 [October 2023]
Downloaded:	2470 times

 

[ edit this article | back to article list ]